Pop music has a reputation for being a little shallow at times and not as artistic as other genres. There may be a little truth to that as not every pop song makes the most sense in terms of vocabulary (LOL, cue “Now that I become who I really are” from Ariana Grande’s “Break Free”). But for all the pop songs that aren’t deep, you’ve got a whole category of others that hold some heavy subject matter but are masked by an upbeat pop sound. Those are the songs where you feel like you’re discovering something special as it forces you to listen with more intent and challenge the norms of what pop has become known to be.

Hilary Duff’s new album luck… or something is one of the last releases that both fans and critics never expected to be packed with rich and relatable lyrical content. She’s made it clear though that with her return to music, she was going to be doing it her way and on her terms. Hilary is 38 years old now, and the topics she is singing about are experiences that many people in their 30s can relate to on some level. She tackles strained relationships with both her sister and her father on the songs “We Don’t Talk” and “The Optimist” respectively, confirming long-standing online theories about her family over the years. Other songs like “Weather for Tennis” and “Future Tripping”, which are arguably the most pop-sounding songs on the record, candidly address her insecurities in her, whether it’s arguments between her and her husband or fears over whether he will want to leave her in future years. It’s that imposter syndrome of when you have something great going with someone and feeling like maybe you don’t deserve it and it’s all going to fall apart. Hilary of course is married to musician Matthew Koma with whom she wrote this entire album, so it’s even more interesting to listen to her singing about whether she’s having enough sex with her man when the man himself is in the room helping write the lyrics and produce the music. It takes couples therapy to a whole new level. Finally, you have Hilary dealing with the struggles of growing up in the industry and forever being compared to her younger self on “Adult Sized Medium”. That song had me crying upon the first listen because I truly felt seen as someone who struggles with becoming the person I feel I need to be but still honouring the person I was. It’s deep for me, and all a welcome return to the world of music for an artist that up until this point was known for more surface-level teeny bopper tunes. She herself says in a recent interview that she didn’t feel like “sophisticated songwriting” was the intent back then, even making the connection to Taylor Swift’s songwriting to “before Christ and after Christ”, LOL. This is Hilary’s magnum opus, and she laid out her most personal feelings and experiences in the process.

The idea of a darker or deeper subject matter being masked by fun upbeat energy is not a new idea of course. Britney Spears sang about the troubles of fame over a Swedish bubble gum instrumental on “Lucky” and Foster The People sang about a school shooting on “Pumped Up Kicks”. That song became one of the biggest radio hits of 2008 with a melody so catchy that I you just can’t help but sing the lyrics no matter how shocking they are. Third Eye Blind even had a song about someone on a full-on drug bender in “Semi-Charmed Life”. This trick has been used often and when it’s done well, it’s very effective.

Next week is Bruno Mars’s big album release which serves as his first solo album in close to a decade. The first single “I Just Might” has topped the charts already, so the hype is real. This week sees new tunes from Hilary Duff, Baby Keem with Kendrick Lamar, SZA, Ty Dolla $ign with Leon Thomas, and Bebe Rexha. Plus, Fergie makes a cameo in this week’s column as a viral pick that has content creators sharing their most precious loves.

Listen on…

MC’s PICKS OF THE WEEK

“Weather For Tennis” by Hilary Duff

The opening track to Hilary’s most personal body of work yet is the pop bop “Weather For Tennis” which gives some light 80s meets indie vibes. The song is an honest look at a sometimes-dysfunctional relationship and analyzing each person’s faults and the roles they play in the dysfunction. Hilary describes herself as a “seasoned apologist” who makes excuses for the people she loves while calling her partner “a mouthful of inconsistencies”. One’s unreliable while the other always makes excuses – sounds like your average relationship to me, LOL. To think that the same artist who once sang the lyrics “if the light is off then it isn’t on” is now singing lyrics like “You calling me batsh-t’s the fastest antibiotic for thinking you’re different this time” is the definition of growth. Like I mentioned earlier, I’ve never associated Hilary Duff with quality songwriting (and that’s not a bad thing), but she really surprised me. Hilary’s new sound is not her chasing trends or attempting to recreate her Disney Channel glory days, she built a record and sound that is rooted in truth. There’s no such thing as a perfect relationship, and some dynamics are a bit more complicated. Hilary makes a reference to her own parents’ divorce in the song and how she is a “kid of divorce” which serves as the cause of her constant avoidance of confrontation. So long as love is the root and the safety that is present through every obstacle, some arguing here and there can’t break it. Then you have the melody of the song which is simple yet effective, like the greatest pop songs are. It’s a standout track from the album and has all the right ingredients to be a big radio hit or at the very least could become a top streaming hit on millennial gay men’s pop playlists.

Photo credits: PapCulture/Backgrid

Share this post